I have been living with my girlfriend for 6 months. I am totally into her, and we are a great couple. She has had a friend with benefits long before we met and got together. She told me about it and said she would not give him up. Her reason is that sex with him is amazing, the best she has ever had. She calls him “Fuck Buddy”. I was ok with that, and she promised plenty of wild sex. She likes threesomes and he was up for it. The first one went well with us both wearing condoms.
Then the second time I nutted by accident before I could pull out of her. He and I were spit roasting her and I just couldn’t hold it in watching her take his dick down her throat. She can really swallow it. She is not on any birth control, and she had to get the morning after pill to be safe from pregnancy. She was pretty pissed with me. Normally I have been pulling out before I cum and it has worked ok with that.
It was a while before we had another threesome. But she visited his place on multiple occasions. She then asked me beforehand if I’d be down to try using a condom again so we wouldn’t repeat the last mishap. I agreed and the night went off without a hitch.
She knew that he was infertile because he has had a vasectomy. He is a bit older and has been married before and had 2 kids. She asked me if it would be alright to fuck him bareback if he got tested. Up till then she knew that he had been fucking 2 other women besides her. Things have changed and he is not seeing them.
When his STI tests came back negative, I gave the go ahead. Afterwards, per my request, I received a picture of his cum dripping out of her when she was at his. So sexy.
We planned another threesome. Before he arrived she asked me if I was comfortable with no condoms in a threesome setting. I told her I was totally fine with it, and she said, “obviously you don’t have to wear one either, as long as you don’t cum in me.” I promised to try my best.
The night got underway, and we spit-roasted her. Up until this point I’d never witnessed her take his dick raw and I couldn’t stop imagining it. I could only make it a few thrusts at a time before I was forced to pull out. This happened repeatedly and she stopped sucking his dick a couple times to say, “don’t cum in me, babe!” and “please don’t cum!”
When he grabbed her head and pushed her down into a deep throat it was too much for me. I pulled out and turned to go fetch a condom. But I’d waited just a second too long. It was an unsatisfying half orgasm and my load shot onto the floor.
Without saying anything I headed for the bathroom to clean up and get some tissues to wipe up the mess. She stopped blowing him again to ask what I was doing, and I said something like, “you guys keep going, I just came.” She said, “did you cum on the floor?” and when I nodded and said, “fuck that is so hot”.
I made lite of the situation, and he said, “I don’t blame him, your pussy is too good.”
I walked back to the bathroom and I could immediately hear the bed frame creaking. For a minute or two I just stood there looking at myself in the mirror, listening to my girl moan. When I returned she was bouncing on his unprotected raw cock. Immediately I felt the blood rushing to my dick again. Shortest refractory period of my life.
I took a seat and watched him flip her over onto her back. Her legs wrapped around his waist as he thrust his bare dick inside her. She moaned loudly, “mmmm!” and “yes, baby!” and “oh fuck… your dick!” The groans made him thrust harder, until he began to groan too.
The rhythm of her thighs slapping his pelvis picked up pace. Each breast leapt up from her ribs and clapped together in unison before swinging back down again to complete the quickening loop. I watched her hands slide up his outstretched arms and tightly grip his biceps.
Through grunts he barely managed to let out a warning. She ignored it and kept her legs tightly wrapped around him. In an instant he tensed up, clenching his glutes and letting out a deep groan with every laboured push. When the orgasm had ended he hung his head and exhaled deeply.
Through it all she had been crying “Yes baby!” and saying, “cum in me!” and telling him, "fill me uuuup!"
When the moment passed he excused himself to clean up. As she lay on the bed, her legs still wide open, I snuggled up and kissed her. My hand made its way south and felt his still-warm semen leaking out. I played with her clit, and she squirmed. First, she whispered in my ear, “I’m sorry you couldn’t cum in me too!” and then pulled back with a concerned look and followed with, “you didn’t, right?” I assured her I hadn’t and she told me to fuck her once I put on a condom.
So, after that I fucked her with a condom during our threesomes while he hit it raw. She often says during sex as a couple on how much better sex felt without protection. “It’s a good thing you can last without a condom when Fuck Buddy isn’t here!”
So, it remains that the only time I’ve cum in my girl is once, on accident, during that threesome.
Her Fuck Buddy is her regular, he’s her favorite hookup, and she happily lets him cum inside her whenever he wishes. I’m realizing the only time I ever hear her say “cum in me!” is when she’s fucking him. The contrast between her pulling him closer when he orgasms versus me having to pull away when I ejaculate makes me so jealous. Even though he's just a friend with benefits, those moments of closeness are intimate, even if they're not romantic. I have even thought of a vasectomy, but she still wants kids and so do I.
FUCK MY WIFE!